When a family member wants to lead the business, the assessment carries extra weight. The candidate may be a son or daughter. The person deciding may be their parent. Other family members may have a view, and employees will be watching to see whether the process is credible.
This article is about family members seeking an executive role. Their future as owners and their place in the family are important matters, but they are separate from whether they are ready to lead the business.
Fairness starts with a clear standard and an honest process. It does not require every candidate to have followed the same path or to receive the same outcome.
Fairness means the candidate understands the standard, the process and the reasons for the decision.
Agree the criteria before assessing the person
The board should first define the role and what success will require. What will the person be accountable for? What experience, judgement and leadership will the business need? Which capabilities are essential from the outset, and which could be developed?
These criteria should be agreed before the family settles on a preferred candidate. Otherwise, the role can begin to reflect the strengths of the person being considered, or the standard can change as the discussion becomes more personal.
The criteria should be clear enough to guide a real assessment. For a Managing Director, that might include evidence of leading beyond one function, making sound commercial decisions, building a capable team and handling disagreement constructively. The right measures will depend on the role and the business.
Make the process credible
When a parent is also a founder, owner or board member, it can be difficult to separate personal hopes from the company’s needs. That does not make the decision impossible, but it does make the process especially important.
The board should agree who will assess the candidate, what evidence will be considered and how the decision will be made. The Chair can help keep the discussion focused on the role. Where family relationships make it difficult to have an open assessment, an experienced independent adviser can provide a useful perspective.
The candidate should know what the process involves and who will be involved. Their performance, decisions and experience should be considered alongside structured interviews against the agreed criteria. Feedback from people who have worked with them can add evidence, provided it is gathered consistently and handled with care.
Consider a family member who has performed well as a Commercial Director and wants to become Managing Director. The board may value their results and knowledge of the business, while recognising they have not yet led operations or the full management team. The decision should turn on the requirements of the MD role and the evidence available. The board might conclude that the candidate is ready, identify a specific development period, or decide that the business needs a different appointment now.
A candidate’s potential deserves serious consideration. Readiness needs evidence against the role.
Give development a clear purpose
If the candidate is not ready yet, the family should explain why and what experience would strengthen their case. That might mean responsibility for a larger team, leading a cross-business project, taking on a broader profit and loss remit or gaining experience outside the family company.
Any development plan should have clear objectives and a review date. It should describe a genuine opportunity to build capability, not imply a guaranteed appointment. The candidate needs to know what progress would look like and who will assess it.
This matters because expectations can build over time. A family member may have been encouraged to see the business as their future, or may have turned down other opportunities to remain involved. If the family has made commitments, those should be acknowledged and discussed directly. Silence can leave everyone with different assumptions.
Keep the decision in its proper place
A leadership assessment should not decide a person’s value to the family. Nor should it settle every question about salary, dividends or ownership.
Pay should reflect the work being done. An executive appointment should reflect suitability for the role. Ownership arrangements should be considered separately in the interests of the family and its shareholders. Keeping these decisions distinct helps prevent an executive title from carrying the weight of wider family expectations.
The process should also consider the people who are not candidates. Family members with ownership interests need appropriate information about how the decision was reached and how their interests will be represented. Employees need to understand who will lead and what authority they hold.
Explain the decision clearly
If the family member is appointed, the board should be able to explain how their evidence meets the requirements of the role and give them the authority to carry it out. If they are not appointed, they should receive direct, respectful feedback and understand whether a development route remains open.
The next generation deserves a genuine opportunity to demonstrate its capability. The business deserves a leader selected against a clear standard. A fair assessment allows the family to take both responsibilities seriously, while giving the candidate a decision they can understand, even if it is not the one they hoped for.
About the author
David Twiddle is Managing Partner and Founder of TWYD & Co, leadership advisers to families in business. He works with founders, family owners and boards as they appoint senior leaders, plan for succession and build effective boards. His work focuses on the relationship between leadership, family ownership and the decisions that shape a business’s next stage.